jeudi 24 mai 2012
Lexpress.mu en page d'accueil | newsletter | archives | rss
header
Météo Avis de décès Horoscope   
header
Jailbreak Mauritian Style
Modifier la taille du texte:A | A

Imprimer

Envoyer

Commentaires

Sauvegarder

Noter l'article

Partager et classer cet article

Par:-  Touria Prayag

On 02/07/2010

Between two matches, the nation woke up half-incredulous, bemused and certainly shocked by the jailbreak of the largest number of detainees ever recorded in the history of this country.

As we speak, 27 of these escapees have been recaptured while seven are still on the run. If it were only a question of numbers, I would have congratulated the police for their marvellous work.

Unfortunately, many of those who have been recaptured are the ones who perhaps never intended to escape in the first place or at least had little reason to. One wonders in fact why they ever risked adding time to their sentences, this time in a real prison, instead of just hanging on tight for a little while. So I decided I’d hold on until the Monvoisins and Co., who are still lurking somewhere, have been put back in their cells before I say “thank you” to our police force.

But concerning this whole episode, let’s not be quick in apportioning the blame. What happened here, shocking though it might have been, could happen anywhere. For as long as there have been prisons, there have been prison escapes. Absconding is nothing new and history abounds with cases of daring and amazing jailbreaks the world over. Even a high security prison like Alcatraz, in its 30 years of operation, recorded 14 attempts to escape involving 34 inmates. Though officially, every escape attempt failed and most participants were either killed or quickly re-captured, some detainees disappeared without trace, giving rise to popular theories that their escape attempt was successful.

But what was spectacular about this jailbreak is that there was nothing spectacular about it. It was a far cry from the intricate attempts which saw Frank Morris and the Anglin brothers, for example, burrow out of their cells, cutting through bars and making it to the roof through an air vent then to the shore where they vanished using a raft they assembled.

Over here, the story is not even worth telling. All the ingredients were there, of course: a lot of free time, a healthy portion of desperation and perhaps some complicity. All the prisoners needed to do was to plot, beat some guards up, walk out and disappear into the surroundings. No resistance, no gun shots exchanged, no panic buttons pressed and the out-of-order cameras saw nothing. Above all, no one saw it coming. When rumours swirled that some of the prisoners had made it to “freedom”, there was not a touch of heroism involved to inspire even the simplest of stories.

Naturally, the game that is played from both sides of the law is an unequal one. The detainees have 24 hours a day to plot. The guards have eight hours to catch them at it. But even taking this into account, we cannot help but ask some legitimate questions the main ones being, “was there any connivance on the part of the correctional staff and are our prisons well managed?”

And, more than the questions asked, what is disturbing is the realisation of just how slow justice is; of how long it takes for a suspect to find out his fate; how long small time offenders spend in the “school of crime” before they are tried; how many years the victims of crime sit and wait for justice to be done.

I hope the shock we have had serves as a wake-up call for an overhaul of our legal and penitentiary systems. They badly need it. Let this episode be the silver lining of a cloud which has been gathering in our skies for years.

 


Commentaires

Par Emiliano Z
Jul 08, 2010
And another thing, just because an unoriginal nincompoop, in days best forgotten, tagged our prisons 'la bastille' and 'Alcatraz' does not mean that we must be branded with them forever. Does anyone realise how silly those names sound in the Mauritian context?
Par Emiliano Z
Jul 07, 2010
In cases of alleged violence against law enforcement officers, or whistleblowing against institutionalised corruption, lawyers fearing for the safety of their clients take them to the press before surrendering to the authorities. Not uncommon in civilized countries. Otherwise we'd have the ridiculous situation where an aggrieved party has to complain about an institution which has failed him, to the institution itself. Apart from a supposed confidential communication to a partisanly appointed prison ombudsman, the powerless and often penniless prisoner would have to seek constitutional redress through the privy council. There's a viable option! Nah, we should consider ourselves lucky that we still have unbought and unpaid-for media where citizens can go to air their concerns.
Par PLOUM PLOUM - INDIANS AND BIG CHIEF
Jul 05, 2010
Actually taleb, I beg to differ- " Nobody is in charge" Oh, no. In fact , the problem in Mauritius is that there is NOT ENOUGH INDIANS AND TOO MANY BIG CHIEFS ! ( LOL!! for once I can a laugh on these communal freaks!!!). In Touria's world, the dog of a Sheikh is also a Sheikh. In Mauritius , anyone remotely connected with a Political party or with a Minister is also a Minister and acts like one. How many times have we heard " talère to pou conner, moi mo conne tel tel Ministre ou meme le PM". Here is my take on this "Jailbreak a la mauricienne" . : PRISONS: I have advocated pour la inieme fois, and to successive governments ( All Parties included), the appointment of a Home Secretary (an Interior Minister) to be responsible for Prisons and the The Police. Just like we have in India, United Kingdom and in France. National Security, however, should remain under the sitting PM as is the case currently. My suggestion will have the benefit that a Minister will have daily responsibilities of being briefed of what is really hapenning in our Prisons and of policing our country. He will be free to visit these establishments as he may deem fit. These institutions will then have a clear leadership and clarity of mission and objectives. The Minister, following advice from Experts, and other Ministerial colleagues including guidance from the PM, can come up with meaningful policies to run Prisons and the Police force ( including day to day operations to recruitment, investment, training and accountability etc). Currently and depuis des belles lustres, Policies and strategies are ALWAYS REACTIVE NOT PROACTIVE, Also, as long as there is NO PUBLIC SCANDAL, MAINTAIN THE STATUS QUO. Time and time again, we reap the fruits of such strategies. We have had Experts from UK reviewing our archaic prison’s system, only for their report to be shelved for eternity. What a waste! (as Confirmed by the current PM during PNQ in 2005. I know Mr VijayaNarayaran. He is such a nice person, He simply could not harm a fly even if he is mandated or tried to do so. Sadly such noble personal traits are incompatible with the position of being in charge of Prisons. No wonder, he has never been able to ascertain his authority over simple Officers let alone over Deputy Assistant commissioners who, at least 2 of them, felt that they and not VijayaNarayaran should have been appointed as CP. Indeed both of them possessed the qualifications, experience and profile for the position, save they were from 2 other ethnic communities. Socio-cultural forces, behind the scenes , as always, did their best to push for their protégé! This was how VijayaNarayaran was appointed to the Top position from being a mere if not a dormant Prison Consultant from the Indian Government. No wonder there were continuous “ mette batons dans les rous” to undermine the poor guy’s authority just as was the practice during his predecessor, Bill Duff, who decided to quit than to put up with daily frustrations. By any standards, the position of VijayaNarayaran has become untenable. The least we expect is an inquiry but what we don’t need is the POLITICISATION OF THE SCANDAL, LET ALONE THE FOXICATION ( AS IN FOX NEWS) OF OUR RADIOS ( as in SALESSE’S PROMOTING MONVOSIN’S defence for a most despicable and unlawful acts). Jailbreakers ( be they remands or convicted criminals) SHOULD NEVER BE ALLOWED TO COME ON RADIO TO MAKE ANY CLAIMS , BE IT OF THEIR DEFENCE OR OF ABUSE. WE HAVE INSTITUTIONS TO DEAL WITH SUCH MATTERS. RADIOS ARE NOT SUCH INSTITUTIONS. SALESSE IS GUILTY OF GROSS ERROR OF JUDGEMENT. Name me a country where this is allowed. Would the BBC or FR1 ever got away with such behaviour? There should be a law to prevent criminals and escapees from using radios or newspapers to give interviews and/or defend their actions. For God sake, don’t tell me it is their Human Rights or Freedom of the Press!!
Par Taleb Durgahee
Jul 05, 2010
I do not agree with the sentiments of this article entitled Jailbreak Mauritian Style. If jail breaks are inevitable, then why jail them in this manner? I think the problem is institutional and it starts with the PM. He is PM and in charge of Internal security. He cannot devote time to proper management of security, police and be PM. He should have a Minister for Security including Prisons and abolish some other ministries such as Arts and Culture, Tertiary Education etc etc. The problem is nobody is in charge.
Par Emiliano Z
Jul 04, 2010
Lartik Touria 7 Lartik Finlay 9.5.
Par Yannick
Jul 04, 2010
Reply @ Garam Masala First of all, we are and I do think we will always be a MAURITIAN first of all, there is no majority thus. If you do think and talk like that, it means there is a deep problem and that you don’t consider yourself as a Mauritian. So there is no Asian Majority in Mauritius as we are all Mauritian but there is a majority of Mauritian of Asian origin but not A MAJORITY OF ASIAN in Mauritius.
Par Garam Masala
Jul 02, 2010
You can blame the asian majority for their bigotry, predujices & hegemonic vices, but their racism seems grounded in fact. Consider the profile of the prison population, where they are grossly disproportionately under-represented. One could not help but notice this when browsing the list of names of escapees. Ti-Duval, pas tigit travay to enan pou fer, frere...to kamouad Varma ossi (li bizin montrer ki li merite so la paye sanela!).
Par Rudolph J
Jul 02, 2010
Change does not come at all in Mauritius. Electoral or anything. There is a communal stand which controls all conventions and politics. Yet to show conformity to international norms, we will engage in the Protection of Children, of Woman, of anything the Civilised world establishment wishes us to conform. But the reality of our true state returns with our penentiary system, We simply follow that convicted citizens should be locked up somewhere. That the ' Garde Prison' can indulge in any indignifying conduct and so inflict on the 'inmates'. The 'inmates ' are free to orgainise their ' complot' as there is no other mechanism, no other avenue, there is no concern for the 'inmates'..they are worthless and without rights. We claim to be a Civilised society for we portray Western World styles but behave third Asian Sub continent at home..on the Island of Mauritius. Change cannot come....we are not bothered...preoccupied but with the advancement of the ' majority' community.
Vos Commentaires open close
Actualités|Sports|Génération Y|Mauriciens d'ailleurs|Opinion|Jobs|Immobilier|petites annonces
Contactez Nous | Code de Déontologie | Vos Commentaires | Sitemap
© Copyright La Sentinelle Limited 2010 | Designed & Hosted By: Designed & Developed By 4C plus