| | Juggling various identities | | | | Modifier la taille du texte: | A | | | A | | |
|
| | Par:- Touria Prayag
On 12/03/2010 |
Two score and two, that’s the age of our independent nation today. In the life of a human being, this would ordinarily give rise to a so-called mid-life crisis. For a nation, it could constitute a perennial crisis, imagined or real, of national identity, and it is perhaps an opportune time to ask the question what makes a Mauritian a Mauritian.
Between the time the head of a Mauritian baby is seen and the time the baby is deposited in the cot, he has time to have a trip around the five continents. When he opens his eyes, between the nurses, the doctors and the patients, he has seen what the whole population of the world looks like. As he learns how to speak, he already knows how to address people. He knows who to call ‘Monsieur’, ‘Bhye’, ‘Chacha’ and ‘Uncle’. He instinctively knows which lady he would offend by calling ‘Tantine’ and which one he would displease by not calling her so. By the time he begins to socialize, he has mastered the art of greeting. He knows which hands to shake, which cheeks to kiss and what body language to use from a distance. When he makes his first steps to a place of worship, he has already been acquainted with the other places of worship he will not step into. When he starts entertaining people, he has no problem dealing with all their religious dietary constraints. When he starts cooking, he will know which of his colleagues has a good Kalia recipe and which one will show him how to make ti-puri or mee foon.
That is an awful lot of knowledge. It is an awful lot of culture. It is a tremendous start in life. It is a leg-up over so many children his age who are not fortunate enough to have been born in such diversity.
Unfortunately, he will also grow up in relative insularity, in an isolated island in the vastness of the Indian Ocean, unthreatened by anyone. Having no foe from without, he learns to invent enemies from within. He becomes highly competitive, divisive and his sense of self-preservation will prevent him from opening up to others. He is religious, undoubtedly, but he is more interested in making a show of his religion than in grasping the principles behind it. His sense of family values is very strong but so is his sense belonging to his community. He sees himself fi rst as a member of a community and then as a Mauritian. Of the people around him, the ones he discovered from those early days just after his birth, he knows with whose children he will be playing, the ones he is likely to choose from when he decides to get married and the ones at whose table he will be sitting. About the others, he will speak of tolerance. Not a good enough word but better than many countries have been able to achieve.
Given this multi-dimensionality of the identity matrix, what makes the uniqueness of the Mauritian identity? The way a Mauritian juggles all his identities without any contradiction. He cannot fit in the mould of George Bush, ‘you are either with us or against us.’ He belongs to his community first, but that does not decrease his love for and loyalty to his country or the pride he feels in belonging to it. Don’t ask him to choose. He is happy the way things are. The Mauritian way.
weekly@lexpress.mu
| |
     |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| PLOUM PLOUM- NO DIVERSITY UNDER LAICITE | | | I have news for you Malemn. Mauritius is NOT and will NEVER be a monolithic entity whereby a single substantive political culture can be forcefully imposed onto its landscape. From day one of our history, Mauritius has existed NOT as a Nation of Individuals and citizens but a Nation of COMMUNITIES and a community OF CITIZENS where there is both unity and diversity in BOTH public and private realms. Our Landscape both private and public is and has always been PLURALISTIC AND MULTICULTURAL. Lately Masonic attempts are being made to impose a MONO political culture with its inherent oppressive uniformity relegating our rich diversity not to a Private realm but into an abyss of no return. These Masonic and macabre endeavour stems principally from a fictitious bankrupted and utopic Laicite a la Française, polluting our young minds into believing that our religious, Racial and cultural diversity in anti-thesis to our common sense of belonging and our collective Mauritian identity.
There is no single culture that we all can assimilate under a false concept of Mauritianism. Indeed assimilation, the Trojan horse of French Laicite, is a fabricated fantasy and it depicts intolerance of difference. Assimilation aims at suppressing all differences and creates second class citizens for those who cannot and refuse to submit to a dominant culture. All citizens must by default be integrated into the ONE NATION, but as Roy Jenkins, the Interior Minister in Harold Wilson Government said in a 1966 speech, “integration is not a flattening process of assimilation, but as an equal opportunity, accompanied by cultural diversity in an atmosphere of mutual tolerance."
Our pluralistic identity and heritage is a dynamic one and not a static intolerant one. Our communities, despite its complexities and the ever present threats that it faces, is always in a process of continuous change. It reflects the dynamics of gender, religion, generations, globalisation and even the internet era. Despite their inherent uniqueness, our different communities are not isolated from each other and actually overlap on its own terms, borrowing from each other as it deem fit. There are many examples where members of different communities display a natural ability to accommodate several modes of life as if they are “cross-cultural” navigators.
To ensure that our One Nation Mauritius is a place where every colour is a good colour and where every individual of any community is valued and respected, where racism and discriminations of all forms are not only checked but eradicated from our landscape and above all from our psyche, we need to address a formidable challenge and invites several searching questions. We need to identify a core of COMMON VALUES and loyalties that must be shared by all communities and individuals alike in the One Nation. But such sharing of common good cannot be achieved in a climate of social exclusion. The principle of equal moral worth cannot take root and flourish within a structure of deep economic or social inequalities.Every stakeholder must own up to their responsibilities, be they communities or individual citizens. In addition, we need to strike the right balance so as we can achieve the need to treat all citizens equally yet at the same time treat them differently. A different treatment does not mean a less treatment or an inferior treatment nor does it mean be relegated as second class citizen.
| | | Metertester | | | Thruthometer, Sartre is an iconin France. Yet the French are world champions in blame gaming! | | | Baltazar | | | Mauritius is known as the most cosmopolitan island. Despite different races, communities, religions and cultures which keep Mauritians as individual conservatives, there is a natural born accent due to multi-languages.The Mauritian accent is common and cannot be hidden when talking a foreign language. There is no typical Mauritian but everyone can be proud to be a sort of Mauritian. Proud also to be a citizen of 1.2 millions living in peace and harmony on an island of 2,000 square meters. Yes Touria, if we start analysing and comparing each other we will discover so many different facets which make us a sort of a Mauritian. This is why tropical islanders invented cocktails to have a better taste of life. Happy Independence day. Enjoy to be a citizen of The Republic Of Mauritius. Cheers ! | | | truthometer | | | J-P Sarte said it very well in "No Exit" l'Enfer c'est les autres! This book should be made compulsory reading in Mauritian schools. We might learn how to live with others, not just live next to others. | | | Ben | | | Very good article and it is always a pleasure reading Ms Prayag's articles. | | | Emillie | | | Bravo for the way you juggle YOUR identities, Tooria. Fabulous. You truth flatters at times. At others it should hurt but it doesn't. Because you have achieved what so many foreigners will never achieve : adopting our identity with such ease and finesse.
Happy independence day. | | | Monster | | | I really enjoyed ur insight and your sense of belonging. Glad to have adopted you. Keep it up. | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|