One of the greatest lie ever told is that democracy is “government of the people, for the people, by the people”.  The concept of a “people” exists only at times of tragedy or international competitions.  Past these, the population devolves into “tribes” anxious to preserve and protect its own.  In the United States, for example, the right and the left are now in a “take no prisoners” war mode.  There are few opportunities for inter party collaboration because the Democrats and the Republicans have such different visions of where to take the country that they might as well be leading two different countries.
In Mauritius, there is no philosophy of governing to divide the population.  There are a few major issues where the parties disagree but when push comes to shove, they are no impediment to working together.  Which begs the question: What divides the population in Mauritius?
On the surface, ethnicity and religion seem to be the most important barriers.  In reality, all major parties have long recognized that there is no benefit in a purely communal identity.  What has mattered more is the bond that the leader of each party has created with its electorate.  Navin Ramgoolam has very adroitly exploited the sentimental value of SSR in the history of the country and managed to retain the loyalty of generations of supporters of old Labour.  Similarly, Paul Bérenger retains the sentimental attachment of the old militant family. The PMSD and the MSM are pale imitations of their old self because of the failures of their new leaders
In working towards a new political dispensation, NR and PRB are counting on the sentimental ties of their electorate, which combined will account for possibly more than three fourths of all votes cast.  What if they are wrong?
Even though the Labour Party and the MMM probably have no major policy disagreement, they are two very distinct families, with different sense of themselves.  The MMM thinks of itself as the party of technocrats who knows how to run the government and makes things work.  While it is true that economics matter to everyone, the Labour Party has been more a party with an eye on the cultural aspect of everyday existence.
I suspect that these two views are not very compatible.  Bringing them together may seem like a great opportunity for these two parties’ leaders to change the political game but overcoming sentimental incompatibilities is much harder than removing rational barriers.
If an alliance is indeed formed, it is very likely that there will be a large number of supporters of each party who will find themselves unable to set aside their unease to vote for the new coalition.
Despite his age, SAJ is still a formidable politician. If he decides to retake the helm of his party and bring in a fresh new team, possibly marginalizing his own son (not very likely but who knows?), the year could be full of surprises. The possibility of a new political force emerging out of the blue cannot be ruled out either.
Commentaires
NEW POLITICAL ENVIRONTMENT
I like your comments, but I think it is a good thing for this alliance to happen, this will emerge a new force for the 2020 poll with the young generation to take power because there will be no opposition if the alliance continue until next election and both leaders will reach their mid seventies, I think the MSM will be out in any scenario, the PMSD will stay without any influence.
I think a new leader will emerge as from 2016 after the 2015 poll.
I f we look all ministers now & those of MMM opposition, all of them are overaged to continue.
It can be a new labour party or a new MMM party or a new party.
new alliance
alliance of ptr and mmm is a danger as they want to do a second republic so that navin can become president for 7 years he says he needs more power to solve problems of mauritius but he has all the power now as pm god knows what he wants, a new republic will create conflict among two politician namely berenger and navin , they could not work together once then how can people trust them , the situation of law and order is chatastrophic , crime has increased and killing someone is so easy next election msm should win with jagnauth there was and there will be law and order